Our Menu
Bagels & Bialys
Once Upon's Bakery
Mini Bagels
Each - $0.75 | Baker's Dozen (13) - $9.00
Bagel Balls
Each - $0.85 | Baker's Dozen (13) - $10.20
Skinny Bagels
Each - $1.29 | Baker's Dozen (13) - $15.48
Bagels
Each - $1.29 | Baker's Dozen (13) - $15.48 • Plain, Wheat, Egg, Onion, Poppy, Sesame, All Season Egg, All Season Wheat, Cinnamon Raisin, Blueberry, Corn Rye, Chocolate Chip, Pumpernickel, Garlic, Asiago Cheese, Salt, Pretzel With Salt, Pretzel No Salt
Bialys
Each - $1.29 | Baker's Dozen (13) - $15.48 • Plain Bialys, Onion Bialys, Wheat Bialys, Asiago Cheese Bialys, Raisin Stix
Salad Selection
Shana's Salad
$13.95
Garden Salad
$9.95
Chef's Salad
$13.95
Chicken Supreme
$13.95
Veggie Supreme
$9.95
Tuna Salad Plate
$13.95
Tossed Caesar Salad
$9.95
Tossed Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken
$13.95
Chinese Tossed Salad
$9.95
Chinese Tossed Salad with Grilled Chicken
$13.95
Make Your Own Salad
$13.95
Once Upon A Deli Breakfast Sandwich
Breakfast with Egg, Meat & Cheese
$9.50
Breakfast with Egg & Cheese Only
$8.50
Cream Cheeses
Half Pound or Pound
Plain Cream Cheese
Half Pound - $3.99 | One Pound - $7.99
Chive Cream Cheese
Half Pound - $4.29 | One Pound - $8.59
Cucumber Chive Cream Cheese
Half Pound - $4.29 | One Pound - $8.59
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Half Pound - $4.29 | One Pound - $8.59
Lox Cream Cheese
Half Pound - $4.75 | One Pound - $9.49
Jalapeno Cream Cheese
Half Pound - $4.29 | One Pound - $8.59
Strawberry Cream Cheese
Half Pound - $4.29 | One Pound - $8.59
Fresh Fish
Half Pound or Pound
Nova or Regular (Salty) Lox
Half Pound - $17.98 | One Pound - $35.95
NY Style Sable
$28.95 / Large • Large piece peppered sable.
NY Peppered Sable
$28.95 / Large • Large piece peppered sable.
BBQ Salmon
Half Pound - $14.98 | One Pound - $29.95
Whitefish Chunks
Half Pound - $9.98 | One Pound - $19.95 • Large whitefish chunk.
Creamed Herring
Half Pound - $5.65 | One Pound - $11.29 • Herring in cream sauce.
Wine Herring
Half Pound - $5.65 | One Pound - $11.29 • Herring in wine sauce.
Meats
Half Pound or Pound
Roast Brisket
Half Pound - $9.99 | Pound - $19.98 • Once upon style fresh roasted brisket.
Corned Beef
Half Pound - $10.99 | Pound - $21.98 • Choose extra lean or regular cut.
Roast Beef
Half Pound - $9.49 | Pound - $18.98 • Once upon style fresh roast beef.
Beef Pastrami
Half Pound - $10.29 | Pound - $19.98 • Regular cut beef pastrami.
Turkey Breast
Half Pound - $7.99 | Pound - $15.98 • Roasted deli turkey breast.
Turkey Pastrami
Half Pound - $7.99 | Pound - $15.98 • Delicious turkey pastrami.
Hard Salami
Half Pound - $12.99 | Pound - $25.98 • Nothing better than some hard salami.
Soft Salami
Half Pound - $9.49 | Pound - $18.98 • Soft all beef salami.
Baked Ham
Half Pound - $5.49 | Pound - $10.98 • Delicious baked ham.
Bologna
Half Pound - $9.49 | Pound - $18.98 • All beef bologna.
Chopped Liver
Half Pound - $5.99 | Pound - $11.98 • Once upon's homemade chopped chicken liver.
Hot Dogs & Jumbo Hot Dogs
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $8.98 • Regular or jumbo all beef hot dogs.
Salami Stix
$1.50
Fresh Salads (By Pound)
Half Pound or Pound
Original Tuna Salad
Half Pound - $7.45 | Pound - $14.89 • Our famous original recipe tuna salad.
Gramma's Tuna Salad
Half Pound - $7.45 | Pound - $14.89 • Made with sweet relish.
California Tuna Salad
Half Pound - $7.45 | Pound - $14.89 • Made with green and red peppers, chives and egg-whites.
Chipotle Tuna Salad
Half Pound - $7.45 | Pound - $14.89
Poultry Salad
Half Pound - $6.95 | Pound - $13.89 • Our famous original recipe poultry salad.
President's Poultry Salad
Half Pound - $6.95 | Pound - $13.89 • Made with cranberries and almonds.
Salmon Salad
Half Pound - $6.95 | Pound - $13.89 • Delicious homemade salmon salad.
Grandpa's Salmon Salad
Half Pound - $6.95 | Pound - $13.89 • Made with sweet relish.
Whitefish Salad
Half Pound - $7.75 | Pound - $15.49 • Delicious fresh whitefish salad.
Egg Salad
Half Pound - $5.95 | Pound - $11.89 • Fresh egg salad.
Egg White Salad
Half Pound - $6.45 | Pound - $12.89 • One of our staples... the best around.
Creamy Cole Slaw
Half Pound - $2.49 | Pound - $4.98 • Creamy cole slaw.
Vinegar and Oil Cole Slaw
Half Pound - $2.49 | Pound - $4.98 • Vinegar and oil cole slaw.
Potato Salad
Half Pound - $2.49 | Pound - $4.98 • Potato salad.
Pasta Salad
Half Pound - $3.99 | Pound - $7.98 • Pasta and veggie salad.
Cucumber Salad
Half Pound - $3.99 | Pound - $7.98 • Delicious cucumber salad.
Israeli Salad
Half Pound - $3.99 | Pound - $7.99
Cheeses
Half Pound or Pound
American Cheese
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $8.99 • Sliced American cheese.
Swiss Cheese
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $8.99 • Sliced Swiss cheese.
Muenster Cheese
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $8.99 • Sliced Muenster cheese.
Munchee Cheese
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $8.99
Cheddar Cheese
Half Pound - $4.99 | Pound - $9.99 • Sliced Cheddar cheese.
Provolone Cheese
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $8.99 • Sliced Provolone cheese.
Mozzarella Cheese
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $9.99 • Sliced Mozzarella cheese.
Pepper Jack Cheese
Half Pound - $4.49 | Pound - $8.99 • Sliced Pepper Jack cheese.
Home Made Soups & Chili
Once Upon's Homemade Soups
Soup of the Day
Bowl - $6.69 | Super Bowl - $12.98
Mighty Fine Chili
Bowl - $6.69 | Super Bowl - $12.98 • Delicious homemade chili.
Chicken Combo
Bowl - $6.69 | Super Bowl - $12.98
Chicken Noodle Soup
Bowl - $5.69 | Super Bowl - $10.98 • Bowl or Quart of chicken soup with noodles.
Chicken Matzo Ball Soup
Bowl - $5.69 | Super Bowl - $10.98 • Bowl or Quart of chicken Matzo ball soup.
Chicken Kreplach Soup
Bowl - $5.69 | Super Bowl - $10.98 • Bowl or Quart of chicken Kreplach soup.
Chicken Rice Soup
Bowl - $5.69 | Super Bowl - $10.98 • Bowl or Quart of chicken rice soup.
Chicken Mish Mosh Soup
$12.98 / Super Bowl • Quart of chicken vegetable soup with noodles, rice, kreplach and matzo ball.
Additional Side of Rice
$1.80
Side of rice.
Additional Matzo Ball
$1.80
Per matzo ball.
Additional Side of Noodles
$1.80
Side of noodles.
Additional Kreplach
$1.80
Per kreplach.
Once Upon Favorites
The best bagels w/ cream cheese and lox!
Bagel or Bialy w/ Butter
$3.25
Please provide us with your bagel or bialy choice in the special instructions.
Bagel or Bialy w/ Choice of Cream Cheese
$3.95
Bagel or Bialy with your choice of cream cheese! Please provide us with your bagel or bialy choice in the special instructions.
Bagel or Bialy w/ Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
$12.95
Bagel or Bialy with nova lox and your choice of cream cheese. Topped with slices of tomatoes, onions and cucumbers! Please provide us with your bagel or bialy choice in the special instructions.
All American Breakfast Sandwich
$9.50
Toasted Bagel with eggs any style, your choice of meat and your choice of cheese. Please let us know your bagel flavor in the special instructions.
New York Style Specialty Sandwiches
Specialty sandwiches all served with cole slaw or potato salad & pickle. New York style .... that bigger sandwich! You know what we're talking about!
Hot Corned Beef New York Style Sandwich
$15.95
Served on rye bread with a pickle and your choice of coleslaw or potato salad.
Hot Pastrami New York Style Sandwich
$15.95
Served on rye bread with a pickle and your choice of coleslaw or potato salad.
Reuben New York Style Sandwich
$17.25
Your choice of corned beef or pastrami. Grilled with sauerkraut and covered with melted Swiss cheese. Served on rye bread with a pickle and your choice of coleslaw or potato salad.
Just Sandwiches
Corned beef, turkey, pastrami, roast beef and more!
Roast Brisket Sandwich
$10.95
Delicious homemade juicy hot brisket w/ au jus on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with a pickle slice.
Reuben Sandwich
$11.95
BLT
$8.95
Meatball Sandwich
$10.95
Corned Beef Sandwich
$10.95
Delicious hot corned beef on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with a pickle slice.
Beef Pastrami Sandwich
$10.95
Delicious pastrami on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with a pickle slice.
Roast Beef Sandwich
$10.95
Delicious homemade roast beef on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Turkey Breast Sandwich
$10.95
Delicious turkey on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Turkey Pastrami Sandwich
$10.95
Delicious turkey pastrami on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Turkey Club Sandwich
$11.95
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on your choice of white, wheat or rye toast with a pickle on the side.
Hard Salami Sandwich
$12.95
Soft Salami Sandwich
$10.95
Chopped Liver Sandwich
$10.95
Jaime's freshly made "the best" chopped liver on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with a pickle slice.
Bologna Sandwich
$10.95
Beef bologna on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with a pickle slice.
Baked Ham Sandwich
$10.95
Delicious baked ham on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Salad Sandwiches
Choice of bread
Egg Salad Sandwich
$8.95
Homemade egg salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Egg White Egg Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade egg-white egg salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Poultry Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade poultry salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
President's Poultry Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade President's poultry salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Original Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade tuna salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Grandma's Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade grandma's tuna salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Lucky's Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade Lucky's tuna salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
California Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade California tuna salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Salmon Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade salmon salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Grandpa's Salmon Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Homemade Grandpa's salmon salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
$10.95
Homemade whitefish salad on your choice of bread, bagel or roll. Please let us know your choice of bread, bagel or roll in the special instructions. Comes with lettuce and tomato and a pickle slice.
Tortilla Rollups
Original or Caesar style. On a White or Wheat tortilla
Grilled Chicken Tortilla Rollup
$10.95
Original Style (lettuce, tomatoes, Muenster cheese and honey dijon dressing) or Caesar Style (lettuce, spinach, Parmesan cheese, croutons and Caesar dressing).
Turkey Tortilla Rollup
$10.95
Original Style (lettuce, tomatoes, Muenster cheese and honey dijon dressing) or Caesar Style (lettuce, spinach, Parmesan cheese, croutons and Caesar dressing).
Veggie Tortilla Rollup
$7.95
Original Style (lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, green peppers, cucumbers, Muenster cheese and honey dijon dressing) or Caesar Style (lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, green peppers, cucumbers, Parmesan cheese, croutons and Caesar dressing).
Tuna Salad Tortilla Rollup
$10.95
Original Style (lettuce, tomatoes, Muenster cheese and honey dijon dressing) or Caesar Style (lettuce, spinach, Parmesan cheese, croutons and Caesar dressing).
How About a Side Order
Once Upon's Delicious Homemade Sides!
Bagel or Bialy
$2.25
Cajun Curly French Fries
$3.50
Cajun curly fries.
Homemade Potato Pancake
$3.95
Once Upon's own recipe delicious potato pancakes.
Homemade Veggie Potato Pancake
$3.95
Once Upon's own recipe delicious veggie potato pancakes.
Sweet Potato Chips
$3.50
Creamy Coleslaw
$3.50
Potato Salad
$3.50
Pasta Salad
$3.95
Cucumber Salad
$3.95
Kidney Bean Salad
$3.50
Please hour up to 1 hour for Same Day Catering Orders.
Menu
Relish Tray
$4.95/Per Person
Sweet and dill pickles along with black, green and Greek olives. Minimum 10 people.
Cubed or Sliced Cheese Tray
$4.95/Per Person
Includes assorted cheeses your choice of up to five cheeses. Minimum 10 people.
Veggie Tray
$4.95/Per Person
Our delicious homemade ranch dip surrounded by broccoli, carrots, celery, cucumbers and red & green peppers. Minimum 10 people.
Chopped Liver Appetizer Tray
$5.50/Per Person
Homemade chicken chopped liver served with cocktail rye bread and assorted bread flats. Minimum 10 people.
Fruit Tray
$4.95/Per Person
A delicious blend of fresh seasonal fruits including pineapple, cantaloupe, watermelon, strawberries, grapes, kiwi and more. Minimum 10 people.
Sweet Tray
$59.95
Small feeds 10-15 people $59.95 | Large feeds 20-25 people $84.95 • Includes assorted Leonard’s Bakery cookies, mandel bread, rugelach and pastries.
Breakfast Tray
Small - $59.95 | Large - $84.95 • Includes assorted Leonard’s Bakery coffee cakes, Once Upon’s famous donuts, muffins and cookies.
Small Sliced Bagels and Cream Cheese Tray
$54.95
Includes two dozen bagels with choice of three cream cheeses. Also, includes tomatoes and cucumbers.
Large Sliced Bagels and Cream Cheese Tray
$69.95
Three dozen bagels with your choice of three cream cheeses plus tomatoes and cucumbers.
Small Sliced MINI Bagels and Cream Cheese Tray
$54.95
Three dozen mini bagels with choice of three cream cheeses. Also, includes tomatoes and cucumbers.
Large MINI Sliced Bagels and Cream Cheese Tray
$69.95
Five dozen mini bagels with choice of three cream cheeses. Also, includes tomatoes and cucumbers.
Breakfast Combo Tray
$64.50
Includes one dozen bagels with cream cheese along with donuts, muffins and coffee cakes. (Feeds about 10-12 people)
Salad Tray with Sliced Bagels
$118.50/Large
Includes two dozen sliced bagels with your choice of three salad. Also includes tomatoes, lettuce and pickles. Tray serves 10-15 people.
Mini Sandwich Tray
Per Sandwich - $6.95 | 10 People - $79.50 | 15 People - $119.25 | 20 People - $159.00 • Any assortment of sandwiches on mini challah rolls. Served with pickles and your choice of coleslaw, potato salad or pasta salad. Minimum 10 sandwiches. Please let us know your breakdown of sandwiches in the Special Instructions.
Sandwich Tray
Per Person - $11.95 | 10 People - $119.50 | 15 People - $179.25 | 20 People - $239.00 • Any assortment of sandwiches on your choice of bread, bagels, challah rolls, Kaiser rolls or onion rolls. Served with pickles and your choice of coleslaw, potato salad or pasta salad. Minimum 10 sandwiches. Please let us know your breakdown of sandwiches in the Special Instructions.
Rollup Tray
Per Rollup - $11.95 | 10 People - $119.50 | 15 People - $179.25 | 20 People - $239.00 • Any assortment of rollups served on white or wheat tortillas. Served with pickles and your choice of coleslaw, potato salad or pasta salad. Please let us know your breakdown of rollups in the Special Instructions.
Fish Tray
Per Person - $17.95 | 10 People - $179.50 | 15 People - $269.25 | 20 People - $359.00 • Includes hand sliced nova lox. Three salads of your choice. Plain, chive & vegetable cream cheeses. Muenster and swiss cheeses. Tomatoes, onions, cucumbers and olives. Also comes with two bagels and bialys per person. Minimum 10 people.
Meat Tray
Per Person - $17.95 | 10 People - $179.50 | 15 People - $269.25 | 20 People - $359.00 • Includes lean corned beef, turkey and roast beef and salami- Muenster, Swiss and American cheese- Creamy coleslaw and potato salad- Lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, mayo and mustard. Also includes an assortment of bagels, rolls and rye bread.